Rating: 5 out of 5 boxes
Target Audience: Girls of all ages
High point: Gilbert, the romance, Philippa
Low point: None whatsoever
Reader maturity: 8+
Favorite quotes: "Oh, she thought, how horrible it is that people have to grow up--and marry--and change!"
"I wouldn't want to marry anybody who was wicked, but I think I'd like it if he could be wicked and wouldn't."
While telling my mom about my most recent re-read, I said, "I kept reading faster and faster because, even though I know Anne ends up with him, I was so worried that somehow she wouldn't!." My mom replied, "That's the mark of a good book." And Anne of the Island is certainly that!
There are so many great things about Anne of the Island; for one thing, I love the addition of Philippa. I can relate to the indecision and matter-of-factness in her character. But Anne frustrates me in this one (that's why I mentioned wanting to skip to Anne of Windy Poplars in my review of Anne of Avonlea). She's avoiding Gilbert one minute and getting riled up at a rival the next--and then, her refusal! Fortunately for Anne and her readers everywhere, we get to see Gilbert's best attributes, such as his patience. On my previous read-throughs, I didn't realize just how much she tested him. For some reason, I was under the impression that Anne was a little naive about his intentions, but I guess the point is that she needed to release her idea of perfection and embrace the wonderful person in front of her, just like she did with her dreams in Anne of Avonlea. The sleepless night she spends in her little upstairs room is one of the most touching and intense scenes in literature as the reader waits anxiously with Anne to find out Gilbert's fate.
I can't wait to dive into Anne of Windy Poplars! It's a fun one.
Title: Anne of the Island
Author: L. M. Montgomery
Genre: Children's Fiction & Literature
Book Source: Purchased